Skip to Main Content

Employment Law: Understanding Wrongful Termination. A Research Guide By Cherish Fuller: Introduction

Wrongful Termination in Florida: Exceptions to Employment "At-Will"

Introduction

Florida is an employment-at-will state. This means that either the employer or the employee may end the employment relationship at any time and for any reason. Thus, there is no such thing as a "wrongful termination" claim under Florida law, per se. However, Florida has recognized important exceptions to at-will employment, making certain quasi-wrongful-termination claims possible. These exceptions fit under the following "umbrellas":

I. Public Policy Exception

The public policy exception bars an employer from terminating employees in violation of well-established public policy of the state. As an example, in many states an employee may not be terminated for filing a workers' compensation claim after an on-the-job injury.

II. Implied Contract Exception

The implied contract exception means that an employee may have an expectation of a fixed term or even indefinite employment based on something the supervisor has done. This can take the form of employer's statements, an employer’s practice of only firing employees for cause, or an assertion in the employee handbook that specific termination procedures will be followed.

III. Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing

Under this exception, an employer typically may not terminate an employee in bad faith or terminate an employee when the termination is motivated by malice.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Most Common Occurrences That Fall Within the "Umbrellas"

  • Discrimination: Termination due to race, age, sex, pregnancy, national origin, marital status, color, religion, or disability is illegal in Florida. You are protected from this type of termination if your employer has 15 or more employees (and in some counties, 5 or more employees). You may be able demonstrate you were treated differently than those of a different race, sex, religion, national origin, age, or other protected status under the same circumstances. Try to think of people who are of a different race/age/sex, etc. and were treated differently from you. Find out if there are people who have also been the victims of similar discrimination. If only people of a particular race, etc. have been terminated for a particular violation, where others have only been warned, this would be discrimination.
  • Reporting or objecting to discrimination: If you were sexually harassed or the victim of other discriminatory harassment based upon race, age, religion, national origin, marital status, color, or disability, you can’t be fired in retaliation for reporting such harassment.
  • Objecting to or refusing to participate in discrimination, harassment, or illegal activity: If the employer has 10 or more employees, you may be a protected whistleblower.
  • Making a worker’s compensation claim: It is illegal to terminate you for making such a claim.
  • Taking leave due to bereavement, sickness, disability, or serious medical condition of a family member: If you worked at least 12 months (can be non-consecutive) and the employer has 50 or more employees, you may have a Family and Medical Leave Act claim.
  • Being owed overtime or wages: You cannot be terminated for objecting to not being paid or objecting to improper classification of you as an exempt employee not entitled to overtime.
  • Testifying against the employer or in any court case where subpoenaed: You can’t be terminated for your testimony under subpoena.
  • Pregnancy: You can’t be terminated for your pregnancy, or because you recently gave birth and the employer has stereotypical beliefs about women with children.
  • Breach of contract: If you have a contract that says you can only be terminated for cause, the employer may have to pay you for the entire length of the contract if they end it early.
  • Being over 40: In a layoff or redundancy, the employer is supposed to provide you with a list of the ages of the others laid off or made redundant so you can determine whether or not age discrimination has occurred.

Definitions

Employment: the act of engaging in work, the consumption of a person's time and energy to the task at hand in an occupation, profession, trade or business.

Employment At-Will: either employer or employee can end the relationship without liability; as long as there is the understanding that the employment is at will, either party can terminate employment at any time.

Discrimination: termination due to race, age, sex, pregnancy, national origin, marital status, color, religion, or disability.

Employee: a person in the service of another. The employment contract can be written, oral or implied. The employee's activities while performing work are subject to the control of the employer.

Employer: a person or entity (such as a partnership or corporation) which obtains the services of another to perform work. The employer provides the means through which the services will be performed (such as providing a place where the work is to be performed and the tools required to get the work done). The employer has direct control over the manner in which the work is to be performed.

Key Concepts

Florida is an employment “at-will" state. In an “at-will” state, both employer and employee are presumed to be working through their own volition with no long-term contractual obligation to each other. An employee may leave their employer at any time without the employer taking action against them. Conversely, the employee can be terminated without cause and with no legal recourse against the employer. 

Key Elements of an "at-will" state:

  1. Your employer is free to fire you without cause (with some exceptions).
  2. You are free to leave your employer and take another position.
  3. Your employer has no long-term contractual obligation to you.
  4. You have no long-term contractual obligation to your employer.
  5. Your employer is free to cut your hours, transfer you, or demote you without cause.
  6. There may be instances of wrongful termination in “at-will” states if certain exceptions to "at-will" employment apply.

When Can a Lawsuit be Filed Against a Florida Employer?

  • The employer is breaking state or federal law — e.g., firing you violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
  • The employer violates the public interest — e.g., you have been fired for refusing to perform an illegal act or being a whistleblower.
  • Firing you goes against an implied contract — e.g., your employer’s established practice is not to terminate people without cause.
  • The employer breaks a covenant of good faith — e.g., they fire you months before you can collect a pension.
  • You take leave under the Family Medical Leave Act, or for jury duty, or for active military duty and the employer fires you.
  • The employer fired you in retaliation for an action you took — e.g., you reported sexual harassment in the workplace to local law enforcement.
  • You acted as a whistleblower and were fired — e.g. you contacted federal authorities with information about your employer’s intentional violation of federal law.

DISCLAIMER

THIS RESEARCH GUIDE/PATHFINDER IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE AND DOES NOT ESTABLISH ANY ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP.
PLEASE CONTACT AN ATTORNEY FOR LEGAL ADVICE.

Search the Library to locate books, e-books, videos, articles, journals...
Search For

Other Search Options